Taare Zameen Par

This movie, like Lagaan, is one heck of a pathbreaker. Like Lagaan, I can't see any other producer financing a movie like this. Taare Zameen Par casts light on a problem that the world refuses to acknowledge.

TZP is the story of a dyslexic child and his struggle with conforming with the world and competing with it as every child his age is forced to do. But the gem in the script and direction is that you can replace dyslexia with just about any hidden problem in children today, and an equally poignant movie can be made. The movie is full of analogies that make the audience understand the protagonist in the same way that he understands the world. However the best analogy comes in the second half, when dyslexic children are compared with the mentally retarded ones. As sad and pitiable the condition of the latter is in our society, at least we recognize their deficiency. The former get to face their problems without so much as an acknowledgement from anybody else that the problem even exists. And this portrayal allows every audience member to relate the movie to his/her personal life--whether it be dyslexia, or even a simple hatred for maths and science.

TZP succeeds in portraying the problem and offering a cinematic solution without being jingoistic, preachy and idealistic. A teacher diagnoses dyslexia because he was himself one and he works with such children. Parents bring up their children by only comparing their own with others'. They refuse to recognize their child's problem because the world refuses to recognize it. And even when they do, saving their own face as potentially bad parents comes before actually realizing what their child is going through. And ample proof and examples are provided to state that dyslexia is not a one-way street to the mental asylum, neither is it the end of the road for any future achievers. So much so that it makes the rest of us feel bad about not being one of the elite dyslexics!

Aamir the director has done a fine job and has admittedly been helped by a dream script. The credit of trusting the script, financing it and then making a product that resists all temptations to include crowd-pulling story-detractors goes solely to him. Apart from 1-2 songs, Aamir's direction is at its absolutely best during all the songs and is ably complemented by Shankar Ehsaan Loy's soothing scores and Prasoon Joshi's poignant poetry. The pace of the movie meanders between captivating and locally pointless, but the former moments stick with us far more. The genius of Amole Gupte shines through in the concept of the movie, his research on the topic, and the meaningful portrayal of the child's emotions through his simple paintings. The movie promises to be a pathbreaker from the very first frame when it acknowledges all parents and teachers that they interviewed, instead of a slew of commercial thank-yous to channels, banks and sponsors.

The cast is perfect. Inspite of being a die-hard Aamir fan, I couldn't help but feel that Akshaye Khanna of DCH would've been an equally powerful candidate for Aamir's role in the movie. Aamir's greatest contribution as an actor in this movie is that he has stepped aside and let Darsheel Safary get all the limelight. Although his tears upon realizing Darsheel's dyslexia seem a bit contrived, his overall portrayal is very Denzel Washington--keeping it simple with just a sprinkling of cinematic acting. Tisca Chopra as the helpless mother is quite good. Her character is beautifully etched as a well-meaning mother torn between her husband's wily discipline and her son's helplessness. I'm sure most students will relate to the father in the movie :-). Darsheel Safary, for a kid that young, is very versatile as an actor.

All in all, a movie with a superstar acting, directing and producing and not having any of the following: (1) Swiss locales (2) a single love story (or even a heroine) (3) item songs/celebrity guest appearances (4) odes to the patriotic (read rich) NRI. Go Amole and Aamir!
Amit

Aaja Nachle: the review

A simple story, quite predictable, with only one famous actor (trying to make a comeback), a debutant director and yet quite a nice, successful and appealing product: Aaja Nachle.

The premise of Aaja Nachle is Madhuri Dixit, who is settled in the US, having long moved on from her past life in India. News of her guru's impending death brings her and us face-to-face with her past: her parent's aspirations and her lover's dreams quashed by her romance with an American photographer encouraged by her liberal dance guru. Upon return she discovers that the disdain of her fellow Shamilites about her hasn't decreased, and her dance school is in the danger of being replaced by a shopping mall.

So she sets off to make her small town realize the importance of having a dance school, and to a certain extent, find and repair her long-lost roots. Thus begins the quest for a Laila-Majnu play, realized by the most unusual and incompetent of Shamili's home-grown would-be talent.

Nothing about the story jumps out at you. Everything (eventually) happens as one would predict. The movie is peppered with small wins: how Madhuri convinces the local politician, how she motivates her actors, above-average music by Salim Sulaiman and decent performances by everybody. The best part of the movie however, is the climax. After hearing Laila-Majnu of all things in the first 40 minutes of the movie, I started resigning my fate to yet another rendition of a very ghisa-pita story, something that I was sure would either be too artsy or anticlimactic for me to appreciate. The play however, is surprisingly well-executed, and is the highlight of the movie because it is good and contextually believable.

Several factors come together to make this movie the perfect comeback vehicle for Madhuri and launching vehicle for the director. A bunch of very talented actors with little star power allow Madhuri to shine through without letting it be a one-(wo)man cinematic effort. It is downright impossible to believe she is a mother of two and nearly 42 years old. She looks as if she never aged, she dances as if she never stopped, she acts as if she never left. Very competent performances from Konkona Sensharma, Kunal Kapoor (from RDB), Raghuvir Yadav (Mungerilal), Ranbir Shorey, Vinay Pathak and Yashpal Sharma make the movie complete. A brief but well-executed cameo by Akshaye Khanna is also worth mention. A surprise of sorts among all of the above however is Vinay Pathak, as one gets to see his dance moves in this movie. Many conventional stars couldn't have done a better job.

Overall, certainly worth a watch if you like movies that don't necessarily have one big crowd-pulling (f)actor.